E-signatures under eIDAS, with Sweden as an example

Under the EU eIDAS Regulation an electronic signature may not be denied legal effect solely because it is electronic or not qualified, and a qualified signature has the equivalent legal effect of a handwritten signature. The levels and their legal effect are the same in every EU member state, so you choose the level by how much evidence you need. This guide sets out the EU rules first and then uses Sweden as the example: Swedish law rarely imposes form requirements on signatures, and a few exceptions, such as the purchase of real property, are important to know.

Updated by Nils-Erik Jansson

Three levels under eIDAS

The eIDAS Regulation defines three levels of electronic signature, and they are the same throughout the EU [1].

Level What it requires When it is needed
Electronic signature (often called a simple electronic signature) Data in electronic form that the signatory uses to sign, such as a name typed in a field or an image of a handwritten signature Enough where no level is required, but easy to forge and cannot be linked to the signatory [4]
Advanced electronic signature The requirements in article 26: uniquely linked to the signatory, capable of identifying the signatory, created under the signatory's control, and linked to the document so that any later change is detectable Public authorities and other public bodies often require it. Enough for most commercial contracts if the evidence is good
Qualified electronic signature An advanced signature created by a qualified signature creation device and based on a qualified certificate When a counterparty, an authority or foreign law requires it. Under article 25(2) it has the same legal effect as a handwritten signature

Article 25(1): an electronic signature shall not be denied legal effect and admissibility as evidence in legal proceedings solely on the grounds that it is in electronic form or that it does not meet the requirements for qualified electronic signatures. Article 25(2): a qualified electronic signature shall have the equivalent legal effect of a handwritten signature [1].

For a legal team in any EU member state this means two things. A simple or advanced signature is not invalid because it is not qualified. And what decides a dispute is what can be proved: who signed, when, and whether it is the same document. In practice the four requirements for the advanced level in article 26 describe the evidence you need.

What evidential value rests on

Four things, whatever the vendor. Identification: how the service knows who signed, for example with an e-ID, email verification or a qualified service. Time stamp: when the signature was made, from a source other than the signer's own computer. Document integrity: the document is locked after the last signature and any later change is visible. Signing log: a record of all of this that travels with the document and can be read without the service.

The fourth is what you need when the contract is challenged. A service that can only show the log inside its own interface is worthless when the contract is challenged eight years later and you have changed vendor.

Sweden as an example

The eIDAS levels apply in Sweden as in the rest of the EU. What follows shows how they meet national law, using Swedish law and Swedish authorities.

What Swedish law requires

The Swedish act that supplements eIDAS (Act 2016:561) governs certification, supervision and fees and contains no form requirements of its own for contracts [2]. Form requirements, where they exist, are in the statute that governs the contract type. Most commercial contracts have no form requirement at all: a sale of goods agreement, a supplier agreement, a non-disclosure agreement or a consultancy agreement is valid whether it is signed electronically, on paper or concluded by conduct. The signature is evidence.

The exceptions are few and important. Under chapter 4 section 1 of the Swedish Land Code (jordabalken), a purchase of real property requires a deed of purchase signed by the seller and the buyer, stating the price and a declaration that the property is transferred. A purchase that does not meet the requirements is invalid, and under chapter 4 section 29 the form requirements apply in part to gifts as well [3]. The statute says the deed is to be signed without saying in what form. What Lantmäteriet, the Swedish land registry, accepts when you apply for registration of title is set out by Lantmäteriet and should be checked there before each property transfer. In the same way, Bolagsverket, the Swedish Companies Registration Office, sets out its own requirements for signatures on documents filed with it. I do not set out those requirements here, because they change and should be read in the original when you need them.

DIGG, the Swedish Agency for Digital Government, describes the same three levels and writes that the organisation introducing e-signatures decides which level to use [4].

Practical rule: if the contract type has a statutory form requirement, read the requirement and the authority's practice before you sign electronically. If it has none, choose the level by how much evidence you need.

BankID and the levels

For Swedish signers, BankID, the Swedish e-ID, is the usual identification method. Foreign counterparties need something else: email verification, another e-ID or a qualified service in their own country.

BankID is an identification method. An e-signing service that uses BankID to identify the signer and then builds a signature that meets article 26 delivers an advanced signature. A service that only lets the signer log in and then writes a name into the document does not. The user cannot see the difference. It shows in the service's technical description and in what the vendor is prepared to put in the contract. Ask: which eIDAS level does the signature reach, and how is that shown in the evidence package?

What to require of the service

  • Written confirmation of the eIDAS level for each identification method.
  • Identification for domestic and foreign signers.
  • Signing order and delegation.
  • Document locking and a third-party time stamp.
  • An exportable evidence package in an open format, readable without the service.
  • Validation: how the recipient checks the signature, which DIGG points out the recipient must be able to do [4].
  • Long-term preservation: how the signature stays verifiable when certificates expire.
  • Data processing agreement, storage location and deletion.
  • Exit with the evidence packages intact.
  • A price per signature or per user that can be compared over three years.

The points are the same whether signing is a standalone service or part of a CLM system; see point three in the CLM requirements checklist.

Choosing an e-signing service is part of legal technology selection when it is done together with a contract management system, and it can be done as a technical vendor review of a single service. The form question for a particular contract type is legal advice in your matter and belongs with you or your law firm. HOVR Legal makes sure the question is asked before the service is bought.

Frequently asked questions

Will an e-signature hold up in court?
Under article 25(1) of eIDAS it may not be rejected solely because it is electronic or not qualified [1]. What then decides the matter is the evidence: that you can show who signed, when, and that the document has not changed since. The signing log, the identification and the document locking are there to show that. A service that cannot hand over that evidence package in a format readable in ten years has a problem, whatever the level.
Do we need a qualified signature to be safe?
Rarely in Sweden. Under article 25(2) a qualified signature has the equivalent legal effect of a handwritten signature, but Swedish law has few form requirements that call for a signature in a particular form at all, and DIGG, the Swedish Agency for Digital Government, writes that the organisation introducing e-signatures decides which level to use [1] [4]. The advanced level with good evidence is enough for most commercial contracts. A qualified signature becomes relevant when a counterparty, an authority or foreign law requires it.
Is a signature with BankID an advanced electronic signature?
It depends on the service. BankID, the Swedish e-ID, identifies the signer. If the signature then meets the requirements in article 26 of eIDAS (uniquely linked to the signatory, capable of identifying the signatory, created under the signatory's control, and linked to the document so that any change can be detected), it is advanced [1]. The e-signing service builds that construction, and the service should state which level it reaches. Ask for the answer in writing.

Sources

  1. [1]Förordning (EU) nr 910/2014 (eIDAS), konsoliderad 2024-10-18, artikel 3.10 till 3.12, 25 och 26, EUR-Lex, in Swedish (Swedish-language version of the eIDAS Regulation); consolidated text with the amendments made by Regulation (EU) 2024/1183
  2. [2]Lag (2016:561) med kompletterande bestämmelser till EU:s förordning om elektronisk identifiering, Regeringskansliets rättsdatabaser, in Swedish; the Swedish act supplementing the eIDAS Regulation, in the Government Offices' legal database
  3. [3]Jordabalk (1970:994), 4 kap. 1 §, Regeringskansliets rättsdatabaser, in Swedish; the Swedish Land Code, chapter 4 section 1
  4. [4]E-underskrift, DIGG, Myndigheten för digital förvaltning, in Swedish; the Swedish Agency for Digital Government; page updated 28 February 2025

Insights on the topic

Back to Technology selection

More under Technology selection