Legal technology selection: from need to decision

HOVR Legal leads the selection of a legal tech, CLM or AI tool from need to decision: requirements, a long and a short list, questions before the demo, a demo on your own contracts, a pilot against fixed criteria and a decision paper. Each step can be done on its own.

Step by step

# StepWhat is doneWhat you have afterwards
1Needs and requirementsVolumes, contract types, systems to connect and data protection requirements. Each requirement is marked as threshold, important or nice to haveA requirements list, see the CLM requirements checklist
2Long list to short listA review of the market against the threshold requirementsA long list with reasons for each vendor, and a short list
3Questions before the demoWritten questions on architecture, data flow, models, sub-processors, exit and priceThe vendors' answers, in comparable form
4A demo on your own contractsThe same documents and tasks for everyone, two assessors from the legal functionA scored comparison, see a demo on your own contracts
5A pilot against fixed criteriaCriteria and the levels for a yes are written before the pilot startsResults against the criteria, see pilot criteria
6Decision paperSummary and recommendationA decision paper with contract points and a plan for the implementation

Who it is for

Legal departments and law firms that are about to choose a contract management system, a matter management system, an e-signature service or an AI tool, and want the choice to be explainable to management, IT and the data protection officer. Also anyone who already has a tool and is considering a switch.

What you contribute

  • A person who owns the decision.
  • Representative contracts for the demo, with personal data anonymised.
  • Two assessors from the legal function for the demo.
  • Pilot participants, from both the lawyers and the business.
  • Contact with IT and the data protection officer.

What is not included

Implementing the chosen tool, which is a separate engagement, see implementation. Negotiating the contract with the vendor beyond the contract points in the decision paper. Full data protection documentation for the chosen tool, which is done in the implementation or on its own under AI for legal. Penetration testing or a security audit.

What it is

Legal technology selection takes the legal function from need to a decision on a tool, before a contract is signed. Every vendor goes through the same steps, with the same documents, questions and criteria. The demo and the pilot follow the LegalBenchmarks.ai evaluation framework, which sets out criteria developed by practising lawyers and a staged evaluation [1], with the additions for Swedish conditions described under technology selection.

From the founder

I have taken part in complex procurements both as a buyer and as a seller. That is why I can tell which requirements a large company should set and which are enough for a smaller one.

Nils-Erik Jansson, founder of HOVR Legal

What is included

  1. Needs and requirements. Interviews with the people who will use the tool and with IT, and the requirements list with threshold requirements marked. Data protection and exit are threshold requirements.
  2. Long and short list. A review of which tools exist for the need, what each one is built for and who it suits. The short list is kept short enough for every vendor on it to show the tool on your own contracts.
  3. Questions before the demo. A list of questions sent to everyone on the short list, with the answers compiled. Questions for CLM vendors can be built in the RFI starter kit.
  4. Demo. The sample of your contracts and the tasks are prepared with you, the demos are run the same way, and the assessments are compiled.
  5. Pilot. Criteria, participants, logging and a decision meeting booked before the pilot starts.
  6. Decision paper. What sets the options apart, what the risks are, what should go into the contract with the vendor, and a recommendation.

The technical review of a single vendor can be added as a separate step between the demo and the pilot. It can be done for the tool in the lead, or on its own. Data protection is assessed in the same way for every option, see AI for legal.

What you get

  • The requirements list.
  • The long and the short list, with reasons.
  • The list of questions with the vendors' answers.
  • The demo protocol and scoring.
  • The pilot criteria and results.
  • The decision paper, in your template, written so that both the general counsel and IT can read it.

Independence

HOVR Legal takes no payment from any vendor under evaluation. What applies if HOVR Legal has an interest of its own in a tool is set out under technology selection.

Time

Scope and time are agreed in the first conversation. If you need help with only one of the steps, such as just the requirements list or just the demo, the step can be done on its own.

Next step

One hour on what you are choosing and where you stand today. Write to hello@hovrlegal.com.

Read also CLM requirements for a Swedish legal team and pilot criteria for legal tech.

Insights on the topic

Ask a question or choose a time for a conversation.

Get in touch

Back to Technology selection

More under Technology selection