, Nils-Erik Jansson

What good legal tech buyers do

The buyers I have seen succeed with legal tech had their process, roles and authorisation defined before they bought, and they decided in advance what a successful pilot would look like. Everything on this page is my own experience from selling to legal departments, and my reasoning from it. I looked for studies that carry the same points and found none I could rely on.

Process first, and tools that were in the way

There are great buyers out there. The most successful ones I have seen were process oriented. They had clearly defined roles, jobs to be done, process and authorisation. Their problem was that the tools they had were a hindrance to that process. A new tool then has something to fit.

Success criteria before the pilot

One European company on the Fortune Global 500 list ran a very structured purchase, with KPIs for the pilot and a definition of what counted as success. It was uncomfortable for the legal team, which had to start measuring things it had not measured before.

I think that should always be part of a purchase, and it is not difficult. It puts the legal team and the IT or business systems team in the right frame of mind. Where do we want to improve, why, and by how much? What would a successful implementation look like?

Organisations used to change

Some organisations have change in their DNA. I have seen it in global groups and in smaller companies, and it helps a great deal. An organisation less used to change, digital or otherwise, has in my experience a harder time implementing technology.

Why legal departments start behind

It is understandable that a general counsel or a legal department may not be strong at process, strategy and operations. Historically those were not taught at law school or learned at a law firm, and that shapes a person. It may be different today, with cross-functional roles such as legal operations.

Legal operations works well when the role goes to someone for their mindset. When it goes to a junior for being from another generation than the general counsel, that person gets a hard start.

Personality more than age

I believe personality decides more than age does. Some of the best people in legal tech I have worked with were over 60. They had an engineering mindset, and perhaps a growth mindset. This is my belief from the people I have worked with. I have no study for it.

Structure first, then the tool

The hardest purchases I have been part of were the ones where the tool was expected to do the changing: no defined processes or roles yet, and a hope that the software would supply them. I understand the hope. In my experience technology applied on top of structure, control and defined roles works, and technology in place of them does not. The good news is that the structure can be built first, and it is the cheaper part.

Who runs the purchase, and who legal works with

Over the years I saw fewer general counsel and more junior staff in the early stages of a purchase, because there were more vendors to filter. The early rounds are where fit is decided, so it helps when someone with the general counsel's overview stays close to them. I mean mainly small and mid-sized legal teams without legal operations. In a large team with legal operations and good support from IT and purchasing, it is natural that the general counsel is less involved.

The relation between legal and the other departments is also crucial. One of the five best rollouts I have done was at a global consumer brand. I had no contact with legal during a twelve-month RFI and the first twelve months of the rollout, because the business systems department was strong enough to run it. The tool is still in use there and has spread to more parts of the group. I think that company is unusual, in its culture, in its business systems department, and in the individuals there.

Nobody is to blame

I do not think anyone is to blame for how hard this is, buyers included. I think it is natural in a market in the state legal tech is in now.

Next step

The CLM requirements list starts with three numbers about your own contracts. The method for a selection, with pilot criteria, is under technology selection.

This text is general information as of the date stated and not legal advice. The assessments are HOVR Legal's own.

All insights