Measuring the legal department: five metrics, no system

Five metrics are enough, and you can produce them without a new system: requests per category and business unit, time to first response, share of requests on the standard route, outside counsel spend per matter type, and contract lead time. All of them can be counted from the inbox and the invoices. Whoever has to show what the legal department does and needs rarely has figures, because there is no matter management system, no time recording, and every attempt to measure ends in an argument about what to count. Here is what the five show and what they do not.

Updated by Nils-Erik Jansson

Why five and not fifteen

CLOC counts business intelligence and financial management among the twelve legal operations competencies [1], and ACC's maturity model describes how measurement develops from nothing to dashboards [2]. Those descriptions are written for departments with their own legal operations function. A department of three lawyers needs something simple. Five metrics are enough, all from data that already exists.

Metric How it is counted Where the figure comes from
Requests per category and business unit Number of requests per category and unit, with a rough size: small, medium, large The shared inbox or the form in a legal front door, otherwise a spreadsheet with one row per request
Time to first response Median time from the request coming in to the first substantive answer, and the share that met the promised response time The inbox
Share of requests on the standard route Requests marked template or self-service as a share of all requests The marking on each request in the list
Outside counsel spend per matter type Law firm invoices totalled per matter type, and the share on fixed fees against hourly billing The invoices, coded with matter type and matter at approval
Contract lead time Median time from request to signature, per contract type The request in the inbox or the front door, the signature in the e-signature service or the archive

1. Requests per category and business unit

What it shows. What the department actually does, and for whom. It is the only metric that answers "what do you do all day" with something other than a feeling.

How it is produced. From the shared inbox, or from the form if you have a legal front door. Without one: a spreadsheet where each new request gets a row with the date, category and business unit. That is the only part that takes discipline.

When I was building a contract management platform, I came across survival rules that had become policy because nobody pushed back, such as "I don't review contracts under 50,000".

What it does not show. How large the requests are. Twenty questions about templates weigh less than one dispute. Add a rough size, small, medium or large, and the picture becomes reasonable.

2. Time to first response

What it shows. Whether the business gets answers in time, as the business sees it. This is the metric that decides whether legal is seen as a bottleneck.

How it is produced. The difference between when the request came in and when the first substantive answer went out, taken from the inbox. Use the median, not the mean, so that one late request does not distort the picture. Also report the share that met the promised response time.

What it does not show. Whether the answer was good.

3. Share of requests on the standard route

What it shows. How much of the volume is handled with a template, self-service or AI support without a lawyer making a judgement of their own. It is the measure of whether the department's work on templates and tools is paying off.

How it is produced. Each request in the list gets a marker: template, self-service, lawyer, outside counsel. The share of the first two is the figure.

What it does not show. Whether the standard route was the right one. Add spot checks: each quarter, a lawyer reviews ten requests that took the standard route.

4. Outside counsel spend per matter type

What it shows. What you buy in, for what, and whether it is the right things. This is the metric the finance team asks for, and the only one of the five that is about money.

How it is produced. From the invoices. Each law firm invoice is coded with matter type and matter when it is approved. After a quarter you see the split, after a year the trend. Add the share of invoices on fixed fees against hourly billing.

What it does not show. Whether the firm was good. It does show which matter types come up so often that it is cheaper to do them yourself or buy them at a fixed fee, see the guide on managing outside counsel.

5. Contract lead time

What it shows. How long it takes from the business requesting a contract to its being signed, per contract type. This is the metric the business cares about, and the one where AI and templates show most clearly.

How it is produced. Two dates per contract: request and signature. The request is in the inbox or the front door, the signature in the e-signature service or the archive. Median per contract type. If the dates exist, split it into time with legal and time with the counterparty and the business.

What it does not show. The quality of the contract or the outcome of the negotiation. Lead time should never be optimised at the expense of the positions in the playbook.

How the figures are presented

One page per quarter. Five figures with the trend against last quarter, one sentence per figure on what has happened, and one decision the department proposes. No charts that need explaining. Management reads it in two minutes, and that is the intention.

Measurement is part of the current state and plan work under legal operations, where the baseline is produced, and of the AI operating model, where the metrics are used to see whether the tools deliver. A legal front door is what makes three of the five metrics come out on their own, and it is built in the legal intake and triage engagement.

Read also managing outside counsel.

Frequently asked questions

Should the lawyers record their time?
Not for the metrics. Time recording in a legal department gives poor data and worse morale, and none of the five metrics needs it. If you want to know where the time goes, an estimate per category over two weeks, once a year, is enough as a calibration.
How often should the figures be produced?
Quarterly for management, and monthly inside the department if it has a legal front door and the figures come out on their own. More often than that nothing changes. Less often and you lose the thread. The first reading after three months is the important one, because it sets the baseline.
What do we do with the figures?
Three things. Show the business what the department does, in its own terms. Support decisions: one more template, one more hire, one firm fewer. And choose what should move to self-service or AI support, since volume per category shows where it pays. A metric that leads to no decision is dropped the next quarter.

Sources

  1. [1]CLOC Core 12, Corporate Legal Operations Consortium, the Business Intelligence and Financial Management competencies
  2. [2]Legal Operations Maturity Model 2.0, Association of Corporate Counsel

Back to Legal operations

More under Legal operations