Legal operations maturity model for small teams
For a department of one to ten lawyers, three levels (basic, defined and managed) and twelve self-assessment questions, one for each competency in CLOC Core 12, are enough. A reasonable target is defined for the competencies that concern day-to-day work and basic for the rest. CLOC's competencies and ACC's maturity model are written for legal departments with their own legal operations function. A department of three lawyers in Sweden that tries to use them ends up with a bad conscience and no plan.
Updated by Nils-Erik Jansson
- Basic.
- It gets done, by someone, when needed, with no written procedure.
- Defined.
- There is a written procedure, an owner and simple follow-up.
- Managed.
- The procedure is measured, followed up against targets and improved systematically.
Business intelligenceDay-to-day
Do you know how many requests the department receives per quarter, from whom and about what?
Financial management
Do you know what the department costs in total, including law firms, licences and time, per matter type?
Firm and vendor managementDay-to-day
Is there a panel, an instruction routine and invoice review?
Information governanceDay-to-day
Do you know where the contracts are, who may see them, how long they are kept and what is kept out of AI tools?
Knowledge managementDay-to-day
Do the templates have owners and versions, and are there playbooks for the most common contracts?
Organisational health
Do you know where the lawyers' time goes and whether the split is reasonable, and is there a plan for who does what when someone leaves?
Practice operationsDay-to-day
Is there one way in for the business's questions and a rule for how they are sorted?
Project and programme management
When the department introduces something new, is there a plan with an owner, a timeline and an end?
Service delivery models
Has it been decided what is done by a lawyer, what by the business with a template, what by a tool and what is bought in?
Strategic planning
Is there a plan for the next twelve months that management has seen?
TechnologyDay-to-day
Were your tools chosen with a method, introduced with a playbook and governed by a policy?
Training and development
Do the lawyers get documented training in the tools and ways of working the department has chosen?
Nothing is sent anywhere. The answers stay in your browser.
Background
Three levels
ACC's model describes maturity in stages from early to advanced [2]. For a small department three levels are enough, and they should be easy to recognise.
Basic: it gets done, by someone, when needed, with no written procedure. Defined: there is a written procedure, an owner and simple follow-up. Managed: the procedure is measured, followed up against targets and improved systematically.
Basic is a natural starting point, and the question is where it pays to move to defined.
Twelve questions
One question per competency in CLOC Core 12 [1], rewritten for a small department. Answer basic, defined or managed.
| Competency | Question | Guide |
|---|---|---|
| Business intelligence | Do you know how many requests the department receives per quarter, from whom and about what? | Five metrics |
| Financial management | Do you know what the department costs in total, including law firms, licences and time, per matter type? | Budget and annual cycle |
| Firm and vendor management | Is there a panel, an instruction routine and invoice review? | Managing outside counsel |
| Information governance | Do you know where the contracts are, who may see them, how long they are kept and what is kept out of AI tools? | Data protection checklist |
| Knowledge management | Do the templates have owners and versions, and are there playbooks for the most common contracts? | Template library as a process |
| Organisational health | Do you know where the lawyers' time goes and whether the split is reasonable, and is there a plan for who does what when someone leaves? | No guide yet |
| Practice operations | Is there one way in for the business's questions and a rule for how they are sorted? | Legal front door |
| Project and programme management | When the department introduces something new, is there a plan with an owner, a timeline and an end? | No guide yet |
| Service delivery models | Has it been decided what is done by a lawyer, what by the business with a template, what by a tool and what is bought in? | No guide yet |
| Strategic planning | Is there a plan for the next twelve months that management has seen? | No guide yet |
| Technology | Were your tools chosen with a method, introduced with a playbook and governed by a policy? | Technology selection and AI for legal |
| Training and development | Do the lawyers get documented training in the tools and ways of working the department has chosen? | No guide yet |
What is reasonable
For a department of one to ten lawyers, my view is that defined on six of the twelve is a good position: business intelligence, firm and vendor management, information governance, knowledge management, practice operations and technology. Those six decide whether the department keeps up with its work and can show it. Basic on the others is acceptable as long as someone knows they exist. Managed on one or two where it makes a difference.
A department that moves from basic to defined on those six within a year has done a lot. That is what a twelve-month plan should contain, in order of priority, with one implementation at a time.
How the assessment is used
The assessment takes an hour and is done by the department together, ideally with someone from outside asking the questions. The result is twelve answers, one sentence per answer on why, and three to five competencies where the department wants to move during the year. That becomes the plan. Next year the assessment is repeated, and the difference is what the department shows management.
How HOVR Legal works with this
The assessment is the first step of the current state and plan work under legal operations, and the first thing an interim head of legal operations does. It gives the baseline for the metrics and the priorities for the next twelve months. HOVR Legal does it with you in half a day and leaves a written picture of the current state and a plan.
Frequently asked questions
- What is CLOC Core 12?
- The Corporate Legal Operations Consortium's description of legal operations in twelve competencies: business intelligence, financial management, firm and vendor management, information governance, knowledge management, organisational health, practice operations, project and programme management, service delivery models, strategic planning, technology, and training and development [1]. It is a map of the field. No department needs to be strong in all twelve.
- What level should a department of five lawyers aim for?
- Defined on the six competencies that concern day-to-day work (business intelligence, firm and vendor management, information governance, knowledge management, practice operations and technology) and basic on the rest. Managed is justified on one or two competencies where the department has a particular challenge, such as outside counsel spend or contract volume. Aiming for managed everywhere makes it hard to get anywhere.
- How often should the assessment be done?
- Once a year, in an hour, by the whole department together. The first time sets the baseline and produces the plan. The second time shows what has moved. The assessment is a conversation with twelve questions.
Sources
Back to Legal operations
More under Legal operations
- Legal intake and triage for business requests
HOVR Legal builds a way in for the business's legal questions: channel, categories, four routes, triage rule, response times and measurement. No new system.
- Contract process design: mapping and redesign before CLM
HOVR Legal maps the contract process with you: templates, approval rules, who signs, where the contract is kept and renewals. Before or without buying a CLM.
- Outside counsel management and external legal costs
HOVR Legal sets up how you manage outside counsel: which matters go out, a panel, engagement terms, billing guidelines and follow-up of the cost.
- Part-time interim legal operations lead
HOVR Legal takes on the legal operations lead role one or two days a week: plan, implementation, measurement and handover, reporting to the general counsel.
- A legal front door for a legal team of three
One way in for the business's legal questions: a form, four routes, response times and measurement. Built for a small department with no new system.
- Measuring the legal department: five metrics, no system
Five metrics from the inbox and invoices: requests per category, time to first response, standard route share, outside counsel spend, contract lead time.
- Managing outside counsel: panel, fixed fees and invoices
A panel of three to five firms, an instruction per matter, fixed fees where possible, three-point invoice review and an annual review.
- Template library and playbook as a process
Why template libraries die and how a small legal department keeps its templates and playbooks alive.
- How to write a contract review playbook
A playbook sets the position per clause: standard, fallback and limit. How to write one for contracts under Swedish law, with an NDA as the example.
- Interim head of legal operations: when and how
When a legal department needs a part-time interim head of legal operations, and what the role does in the first ninety days.
- The legal department budget and annual cycle
How a legal department of one to ten lawyers builds a budget management understands: five lines, invoices as the basis, and a case the CFO can assess.
- The contract process in eight steps, request to archive
A process map for a small legal department: request, triage, template or draft, review, negotiation, approval, signing, archive and monitoring.