Managing outside counsel: panel, fixed fees and invoices

A department of one to ten lawyers manages outside counsel spend through five steps: a panel of three to five firms, a written instruction for each matter, fixed fees and caps where possible, three-point invoice review, and an annual review. Without that, matters go to whichever firm felt closest, on hourly billing, with no instruction, and the invoice is approved because it arrived. Here is how to set out the steps over a year.

Updated by Nils-Erik Jansson

The panel

Choose three to five firms and give each a role. One for day-to-day commercial work, one for employment, one for disputes, and one or two for specialist areas the department often needs. For each firm: a contact person, agreed hourly rates per seniority level, which types of matter go on a fixed fee, and an agreement on how estimates and overruns are communicated. All of it on two pages per firm.

Other firms are not banned. A matter outside the panel needs a reason, and the department knows what it costs to go outside.

The idea of the panel is that the firms get to know the company, hold their prices and get in touch before the budget is blown.

The instruction

Every matter sent to a firm gets a written instruction, even if it is five lines in an email. What the question is, what the answer will be used for, what form the answer should take (an email, a memo, a draft contract), when it is needed, what it may cost or which pricing model applies, and who your contact is. Without an instruction the firm does what it thinks is right, and you have nothing to check the scope against.

The instruction is also what you review the invoice against. Without it there is nothing to review against.

The price

Three pricing models, in this order where possible. The first two are alternative fee arrangements.

Pricing model Used for Condition
Fixed fee Work of known scope: standard contracts, corporate housekeeping, recurring reviews, training First choice
Cap per phase Matters where the scope becomes clear as you go: negotiations, disputes, investigations The firm gets in touch when a set share of the cap is reached
Hourly billing Only when neither of the other two works Agreed hourly rates and an estimate in advance

The share of matters on a fixed fee or cap is one of the metrics you can follow without a system, see the guide on five metrics.

Invoice review

Three points per invoice.

  • Does the invoice match the instruction? The tasks billed are the ones that were ordered.
  • Does it match the price? Fixed fee, cap or agreed hourly rate, and no seniority levels or people that were not agreed.
  • Does it match what was communicated? Any overrun billed was flagged in advance.

Anything that does not match becomes a question before approval.

Code the invoice with matter type and matter when you approve it. That gives you outside counsel spend per matter type, which is the basis for next year's panel.

The annual review

One hour per firm, once a year. What we bought, what it cost, what worked, what did not, and what next year looks likely to bring. The firm learns how it compares with the others on the panel, without figures about the others being disclosed. This is where fixed fees for next year are set, and where a firm leaves the panel or joins it.

The review is also the moment to ask about the firm's own use of AI: which tools, under which contracts, and with what effect on price and on confidentiality in your matters. The guidance from the Swedish Bar Association (Sveriges advokatsamfund) places requirements on the firm, but you are the client and you are entitled to ask. See AI for legal.

What is not worth the effort

E-billing portals with rule engines, for a department with a small outside counsel budget. Detailed outside counsel guidelines that nobody reads. Negotiating hourly rates as the only measure: it touches only the rate and leaves the scope, which is the big cost, untouched.

Outside counsel and cost is one of four areas under legal operations, and the engagement is described under outside counsel management. As a fixed-scope project HOVR Legal sets up the panel, the instruction template, the pricing models and the invoice review, with the first annual review scheduled. Allow four to six weeks for this.

Read also the legal department budget and annual cycle.

Frequently asked questions

Is it worth running a tender for law firms when the outside counsel budget is small?
A formal tender rarely, a panel always. The panel is three to five firms you have chosen for different needs, with agreed hourly rates, fixed fees for recurring work and one contact person per firm. The point is to get recurring work onto fixed fees.
How do we get firms to agree to fixed fees?
By asking for them on the right matters. Recurring, well-defined work of known scope, such as a standard contract, a corporate housekeeping task or an annual review, is where it is most reasonable to ask for a fixed fee. Disputes and negotiations are not, but there you can set a cap per phase, with a duty to get in touch before the cap is reached.
What do we do when the invoice is higher than expected?
Ask, before approving it. Three questions are enough: which tasks are included that were not in the instruction, why the overrun was not flagged in advance, and what the firm proposes. Asking shows that the instruction and the cap were meant.

Sources

  1. [1]CLOC Core 12, Corporate Legal Operations Consortium, the Firm & Vendor Management competency

Back to Legal operations

More under Legal operations