Swedish MBL and AI tools: must you negotiate first?

Under Swedish law, an employer must negotiate with the union under section 11 of the Co-determination in the Workplace Act (MBL) before deciding on a significant change. Whether an AI tool is such a change depends on what the rollout does to the work, because the statute does not mention technology. Negotiation here is a formal consultation before the decision, and the employer still decides. Here is the rule in section 11, how it differs from the duty to inform in section 19, what applies without a collective agreement, and the duty to inform in the AI Act for tools classed as high-risk.

Updated by Nils-Erik Jansson

What the statute says

Before deciding on a significant change to its business, the employer must, on its own initiative, negotiate with the employees' organisation it is bound to by a collective agreement. The same applies before it decides on a significant change to the working or employment conditions of employees who belong to that organisation. That is section 11 MBL, with an exception where there are exceptional reasons [1].

Three Swedish terms need a short explanation. The duty to negotiate (förhandlingsskyldighet) is a duty to call a formal consultation before the decision and to wait until it is concluded. It does not require the parties to agree. An employees' organisation (arbetstagarorganisation) is in practice a trade union. A collective agreement (kollektivavtal) is an agreement on terms of employment between a trade union and an employer or an employers' organisation. An employer is bound by one either by signing it or by being a member of an employers' organisation that has signed it.

The statute mentions neither technology, IT nor AI. Whether an AI tool is a significant change is therefore decided case by case, and that is the assessment the legal department should help HR with.

Three more sections belong in the picture. Section 12: the union can call for negotiation in other matters that concern a member, and the employer must then negotiate before the decision is made or implemented, unless there are special reasons. Section 14: negotiation takes place first at local level, and central negotiation, at the level of the national organisations, can be requested if no agreement is reached. Section 19: the employer must keep the union continuously informed about how the business develops and about the guidelines for personnel policy, and the union has a right to examine documents [1].

What makes a rollout a significant change

The statute does not give the criteria. What follows is my assessment of what decides the matter in practice, based on how the concept has been applied to other changes in ways of working.

  • How many people are affected, and how. A tool that three lawyers use to draft is a different matter from a tool rolled out across the company that changes how customer service, procurement and HR work.
  • Whether tasks disappear, are added or move. When the tool takes over steps that were someone's job, or the rollout is justified by staffing, it is a change to working conditions.
  • Whether the tool measures or monitors. Usage logs, performance data, assessments of work output. Monitoring is a significant change in itself, and it also raises data protection questions: data on employees' use is personal data and needs a legal basis. IMY (the Swedish Authority for Privacy Protection) writes that consent does not normally work in employment relationships [3].
  • Whether the tool is used for decisions about employees. Recruitment, promotion, dismissal, allocation of tasks, performance assessment. Then it is a significant change, and it is also a high-risk system under the AI Act, see below.

A legal department that introduces a configured AI tool for its own work does not normally meet any of the four. In my assessment, a company that rolls out a general tool to all staff meets the first. It should at least ask itself about the other three.

The AI Act's duty to inform

Article 26.7 of the AI Act: before a high-risk AI system is put into service or used at the workplace, deployers who are employers must inform the workers' representatives and the affected workers, under the rules of Union law, national law and practice on informing workers [2]. High-risk under Annex III point 4 covers AI systems for recruitment and selection and for decisions on terms of employment, promotion, termination, task allocation and performance monitoring [2].

Two points to keep in mind. A general AI tool for legal or administrative work is not a high-risk system just because it is used at a workplace; it becomes one if it is used for the purposes in Annex III point 4. And Article 26 belongs to the high-risk rules. Under the original text they apply from 2 August 2026, and under the consolidated text with amendments marked they have been postponed for Annex III systems. There is more in the guide on the AI Act for in-house counsel. Check the date before you plan around it. When the article applies, it is applied in Sweden through the MBL rules on information and negotiation, so an employer that has already negotiated under section 11 has done what the article requires and more.

A three-level rule for the advice to HR

Level When What is done
Inform under section 19 Always: when the AI policy is adopted or changed, and when a tool is introduced beyond the legal department itself. The policy is personnel policy. One meeting.
Negotiate under section 11 The rollout changes ways of working for many people, tasks move, or the tool logs or measures employees. Also when the union calls for negotiation under section 12 in other cases. Call the negotiation on your own initiative, present the material (what the tool does, who is affected, which employee data is processed and on what basis), negotiate to a conclusion, then decide and document.
Negotiate and inform specifically The tool is used for decisions about employees under Annex III point 4. The tool is a high-risk system with its own requirements for the deployer, Article 26.7 applies from 2 December 2027, when the high-risk rules for Annex III start to apply, and a GDPR impact assessment is usually required, see DPIA for generative AI. The legal department should advise against that use until governance is in place.

How the negotiation is conducted, with which arguments and to what outcome, is a matter for HR and management. The legal department's job is to make sure the question is raised in time, that the material is right, and that the data protection part is in place before the negotiation, because the union will ask what is logged and why.

HOVR Legal raises the MBL question in the needs interview in the Claude for Legal setup when the tool will be used outside the legal department, and the material for information or negotiation, including the data protection part, then forms part of the documentation. HOVR Legal writes the guideline in the data protection package so that it can be presented under section 19. Employment law advice in the individual negotiation is not included; that stays with you or your law firm.

Frequently asked questions

Does the union have a veto over our introducing an AI tool?
No. The duty to negotiate in section 11 MBL means the employer must negotiate on its own initiative before the decision is made, and wait with the decision until the negotiation is concluded. If the parties do not agree, the employer decides anyway [1]. What is at stake if the negotiation is skipped is damages and trust. The tool itself is not at stake.
We have no collective agreement. Does MBL apply at all?
In part. The primary duty to negotiate in section 11 applies towards unions the employer has a collective agreement with. Under section 13, an employer without a collective agreement must negotiate under section 11 only on dismissals due to redundancy and on transfers of undertakings. Under section 19 a it must inform unions that have members among its staff in the same way as under section 19 [1]. Introducing an AI tool therefore does not normally trigger a duty to negotiate without a collective agreement, but a duty to inform may exist.
Is it enough to inform under section 19?
When the introduction is not a significant change, yes. Section 19 requires the employer to keep the union it has a collective agreement with continuously informed about how the business is developing and about the guidelines for personnel policy [1]. An AI policy is such a guideline. My recommendation is always to inform, and to negotiate when any of the criteria below is met. It costs little and settles the question.

Sources

  1. [1]Lag (1976:580) om medbestämmande i arbetslivet (Co-determination in the Workplace Act), sections 11 to 14 and 19 to 19 a, Regeringskansliets rättsdatabaser (Government Offices legal databases) (in Swedish), amended up to and including SFS 2026:886
  2. [2]Regulation (EU) 2024/1689 (the AI Act), Articles 26.7 and 113 and Annex III point 4, EUR-Lex (Swedish language version)
  3. [3]Rättslig grund i arbetslivet, IMY (in Swedish)

Back to AI for legal

More under AI for legal